| 2023-10-21 | New York CityvChicago FireMLS · United States | 1–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-10-08 | DC UnitedvNew York CityMLS · United States | 2–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-10-01 | Inter MiamivNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-09-24 | New York CityvToronto FCMLS · United States | 3–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-09-21 | New York CityvOrlando CityMLS · United States | 2–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-09-16 | New York CityvNew York Red BullsMLS · United States | 0–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-09-02 | New York CityvVancouver WhitecapsMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-08-31 | New York CityvCF MontrealMLS · United States | 2–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-08-27 | FC CincinnativNew York CityMLS · United States | 3–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-08-21 | New York CityvMinnesota UnitedMLS · United States | 0–2 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-07-16 | Philadelphia UnionvNew York CityMLS · United States | 2–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-07-09 | Columbus CrewvNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-07-06 | New York CityvCharlotteMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-07-02 | CF MontrealvNew York CityMLS · United States | 0–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-06-25 | Portland TimbersvNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-06-22 | Atlanta UtdvNew York CityMLS · United States | 2–2 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-06-17 | New York CityvColumbus CrewMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-06-11 | Real Salt LakevNew York CityMLS · United States | 0–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-06-03 | New York CityvNew England RevolutionMLS · United States | 0–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-06-01 | New York CityvFC CincinnatiMLS · United States | 1–3 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-05-28 | New York CityvPhiladelphia UnionMLS · United States | 1–3 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-05-18 | Orlando CityvNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-05-14 | New York Red BullsvNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-05-07 | CharlottevNew York CityMLS · United States | 3–2 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-04-30 | Toronto FCvNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-04-23 | New York CityvFC DallasMLS · United States | 3–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-04-16 | New York CityvNashville SCMLS · United States | 2–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-04-09 | New York CityvAtlanta UtdMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-04-02 | New England RevolutionvNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-03-26 | Houston DynamovNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-03-18 | New York CityvDC UnitedMLS · United States | 3–2 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-03-12 | New York CityvInter MiamiMLS · United States | 1–0 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-03-05 | Chicago FirevNew York CityMLS · United States | 1–1 | MLS · United States |
| 2023-02-25 | Nashville SCvNew York CityMLS · United States | 2–0 | MLS · United States |