| 2009-12-28 | EvertonvBurnleyPremier League · England | 2–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-12-26 | SunderlandvEvertonPremier League · England | 1–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-12-20 | EvertonvBirminghamPremier League · England | 1–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-12-12 | ChelseavEvertonPremier League · England | 3–3 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-12-06 | EvertonvTottenhamPremier League · England | 2–2 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-11-29 | EvertonvLiverpoolPremier League · England | 0–2 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-11-25 | HullvEvertonPremier League · England | 3–2 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-11-21 | Man UnitedvEvertonPremier League · England | 3–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-11-08 | West HamvEvertonPremier League · England | 1–2 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-10-31 | EvertonvAston VillaPremier League · England | 1–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-10-25 | BoltonvEvertonPremier League · England | 3–2 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-10-17 | EvertonvWolvesPremier League · England | 1–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-10-04 | EvertonvStokePremier League · England | 1–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-09-26 | PortsmouthvEvertonPremier League · England | 0–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-09-20 | EvertonvBlackburnPremier League · England | 3–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-09-13 | FulhamvEvertonPremier League · England | 2–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-08-30 | EvertonvWiganPremier League · England | 2–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-08-23 | BurnleyvEvertonPremier League · England | 1–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-08-15 | EvertonvArsenalPremier League · England | 1–6 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-05-24 | FulhamvEvertonPremier League · England | 0–2 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-05-16 | EvertonvWest HamPremier League · England | 3–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-05-09 | EvertonvTottenhamPremier League · England | 0–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-05-03 | SunderlandvEvertonPremier League · England | 0–2 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-04-25 | EvertonvMan CityPremier League · England | 1–2 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-04-22 | ChelseavEvertonPremier League · England | 0–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-04-12 | Aston VillavEvertonPremier League · England | 3–3 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-04-05 | EvertonvWiganPremier League · England | 4–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-03-21 | PortsmouthvEvertonPremier League · England | 2–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-03-14 | EvertonvStokePremier League · England | 3–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-03-04 | BlackburnvEvertonPremier League · England | 0–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-02-28 | EvertonvWest BromPremier League · England | 2–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-02-22 | NewcastlevEvertonPremier League · England | 0–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-02-07 | EvertonvBoltonPremier League · England | 3–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-01-31 | Man UnitedvEvertonPremier League · England | 1–0 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-01-28 | EvertonvArsenalPremier League · England | 1–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-01-19 | LiverpoolvEvertonPremier League · England | 1–1 | Premier League · England |
| 2009-01-10 | EvertonvHullPremier League · England | 2–0 | Premier League · England |