| 2023-12-29 | GillinghamvSuttonLeague Two · England | 1–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-12-26 | AFC WimbledonvSuttonLeague Two · England | 0–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-12-23 | SuttonvMansfieldLeague Two · England | 0–2 | League Two · England |
| 2023-12-16 | StockportvSuttonLeague Two · England | 8–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-11-28 | SuttonvCreweLeague Two · England | 1–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-11-25 | GrimsbyvSuttonLeague Two · England | 1–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-11-18 | SuttonvTranmereLeague Two · England | 1–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-11-11 | ColchestervSuttonLeague Two · England | 1–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-10-28 | SuttonvBradfordLeague Two · England | 2–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-10-24 | WrexhamvSuttonLeague Two · England | 2–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-10-21 | SuttonvMorecambeLeague Two · England | 2–3 | League Two · England |
| 2023-10-14 | DoncastervSuttonLeague Two · England | 4–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-10-07 | SuttonvWalsallLeague Two · England | 4–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-10-03 | SuttonvSalfordLeague Two · England | 0–2 | League Two · England |
| 2023-09-30 | Crawley TownvSuttonLeague Two · England | 3–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-09-23 | SuttonvMilton Keynes DonsLeague Two · England | 1–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-09-16 | AccringtonvSuttonLeague Two · England | 4–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-09-09 | SwindonvSuttonLeague Two · England | 5–3 | League Two · England |
| 2023-09-02 | SuttonvForest GreenLeague Two · England | 0–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-08-26 | Newport CountyvSuttonLeague Two · England | 3–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-08-19 | SuttonvAFC WimbledonLeague Two · England | 0–3 | League Two · England |
| 2023-08-15 | SuttonvGillinghamLeague Two · England | 0–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-08-12 | BarrowvSuttonLeague Two · England | 2–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-08-05 | SuttonvNotts CountyLeague Two · England | 5–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-05-08 | SuttonvCarlisleLeague Two · England | 1–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-04-29 | RochdalevSuttonLeague Two · England | 4–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-04-22 | ColchestervSuttonLeague Two · England | 4–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-04-18 | SuttonvNorthamptonLeague Two · England | 1–2 | League Two · England |
| 2023-04-15 | SuttonvLeyton OrientLeague Two · England | 0–2 | League Two · England |
| 2023-04-10 | BradfordvSuttonLeague Two · England | 3–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-04-07 | SuttonvStockportLeague Two · England | 0–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-04-01 | WalsallvSuttonLeague Two · England | 1–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-03-25 | MansfieldvSuttonLeague Two · England | 0–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-03-14 | SuttonvGrimsbyLeague Two · England | 0–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-03-11 | BarrowvSuttonLeague Two · England | 0–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-03-07 | SuttonvCrawley TownLeague Two · England | 3–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-03-04 | SuttonvCreweLeague Two · England | 1–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-02-25 | Newport CountyvSuttonLeague Two · England | 0–2 | League Two · England |
| 2023-02-18 | SuttonvDoncasterLeague Two · England | 2–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-02-14 | SuttonvSwindonLeague Two · England | 2–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-02-11 | HartlepoolvSuttonLeague Two · England | 2–2 | League Two · England |
| 2023-02-04 | SuttonvStevenageLeague Two · England | 0–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-01-28 | HarrogatevSuttonLeague Two · England | 0–1 | League Two · England |
| 2023-01-14 | SalfordvSuttonLeague Two · England | 2–0 | League Two · England |
| 2023-01-07 | TranmerevSuttonLeague Two · England | 2–2 | League Two · England |
| 2023-01-01 | SuttonvAFC WimbledonLeague Two · England | 2–1 | League Two · England |