| D | 2026-03-07 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 1–1 | Championship |
| L | 2025-12-12 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 2–0 | Championship |
| D | 2024-12-29 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 1–1 | Championship |
| D | 2024-12-08 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 2–2 | Championship |
| W | 2023-04-26 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 2–0 | Championship |
| W | 2022-10-29 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 0–2 | Championship |
| W | 2022-02-09 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 2–0 | Championship |
| L | 2021-08-18 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 4–0 | Championship |
| W | 2021-02-02 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 2–1 | Premier League |
| L | 2020-11-28 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 1–0 | Premier League |
| W | 2019-02-23 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 0–1 | Championship |
| L | 2018-12-14 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 1–2 | Championship |
| L | 2010-01-30 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 3–1 | Championship |
| D | 2009-08-29 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 2–2 | Championship |
| D | 2008-02-12 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 0–0 | Championship |
| W | 2007-08-25 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 1–0 | Championship |
| L | 2004-02-21 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 1–2 | Championship |
| W | 2003-10-14 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 0–2 | Championship |
| L | 2002-03-16 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 0–3 | Championship |
| W | 2001-12-08 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 0–1 | Championship |
| L | 2001-01-20 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 2–1 | Championship |
| W | 2000-12-26 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 2–0 | Championship |
| W | 2000-02-19 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 6–0 | Championship |
| D | 1999-11-27 | West Brom v Sheffield United | 2–2 | Championship |
| W | 1999-02-06 | Sheffield United v West Brom | 3–0 | Championship |