| Date | Match | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| L | 2026-05-10 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 3–0 |
| L | 2025-09-18 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 3–2 |
| D | 2025-03-22 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 0–0 |
| W | 2024-09-01 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 4–2 |
| W | 2024-06-15 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 2–3 |
| D | 2023-07-09 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 1–1 |
| D | 2023-06-17 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 1–1 |
| W | 2022-08-07 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 3–2 |
| L | 2022-05-15 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 2–0 |
| L | 2021-07-31 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 4–1 |
| W | 2021-07-18 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 2–1 |
| W | 2021-05-23 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 1–2 |
| W | 2020-10-18 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 3–1 |
| L | 2020-08-25 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 1–0 |
| W | 2020-03-01 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 1–0 |
| L | 2019-08-22 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 1–0 |
| D | 2019-06-02 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 2–2 |
| W | 2018-09-02 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 2–1 |
| L | 2018-07-15 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 2–0 |
| L | 2017-11-05 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 2–0 |
| W | 2017-11-01 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 4–1 |
| D | 2017-10-22 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 2–2 |
| L | 2017-04-30 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 2–3 |
| L | 2016-10-23 | New York City v Columbus Crew | 4–1 |
| D | 2016-08-14 | Columbus Crew v New York City | 3–3 |
League meetings on record only — domestic cup and European ties are not yet in the archive, so this is the league ledger of the rivalry, not every match ever played. Results from PitchVAR's own football warehouse.